Zuma Ordered To Release Zimbabwe Election Report

The report was written by Deputy Chief Justice Dikgang Moseneke and Constitutional Court Justice Sisi Khampepe for former president Thabo Mbeki . It dealt with “legal and constitutional challenges” in the run- up to the disputed election.

Mail & Guardian editor Nic Dawes previously told Business Day he suspected the report would contain information that would contest the view that the disputed election was free and fair.

The P residency said it had no comment.

Unless Mr Zuma appeals , the Mail & Guardian should see the report before June 23.

Judge Stanley Sapire of the North Gauteng High Court is expected to give full reasons for his decision on Monday. The newspaper’s attorney, Dario Milo of Webber Wentzel attorneys, said the order was a “victory for openness, transparency and accountability”.

He said that it proved the Promotion of Access to Information Act had “sharp teeth”. M&G Media, which owns the newspaper, had requested access to the report in 2008 in terms of the act.

It was refused and an internal appeal was similarly dismissed — leading to the court case.

Milo said the order “also makes it plain that even the office of the P residency is subject to the access to information laws and cannot without proper justification keep official documents secret”.

Dawes said the order was a “very important one”.

He said: “I think there’s been a risk that the Promotion of Access to Information Act becomes a dead letter and that no one can enforce it. Business Day

“From that point of view, and from the point of view of finding out something substantive about the information the Presidency has had at its disposal about Zimbabwe — and in particular that crucial election — it’s a very important judgment.”

The 2002 Zimbabwe election was declared “substantially free and fair” by the Southern African Development Community’s c ouncil of m inisters and the Organisation of African Unity.

But the Commonwealth Observer Group said that the conditions “did not adequately allow for a free expression of will by the electors” .

Zimbabwe’s main opposition party, the Movement for Democratic Change, disputed the result. Business Day